From Correct Answers to Defensible Decisions: Learning by Concordance in Orthopaedic Education

Authors

  • Jeff Walter Rajadurai OR PhD in Health Professions Education, Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences, Saveetha university, Chennai, India
  • Jeff Walter Rajadurai OR Associate Professor, Department of Orthopaedics, Madha Medical College & Research Institute, Chennai,India.
  • P. S. Manoharan Professor, Department of Prosthodontics and Crown & Bridge, Associate Dean Academics, Saveetha Dental College, Programme Director, Health Professions Education, Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences, Chennai,India.
  • P Shanmuga Sundaram Department of Orthopaedics, Madha Medical College & Research Institute, Chennai, India.
  • Deepak Nallaswamy Professor in Prosthodontics and Pro Chancellor, Saveetha Institute of Medical and Technical Sciences, Saveetha University, Chennai,India.

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.65521/joe.v4i03.40

Keywords:

Clinical reasoning, competency-based medical education, entrustable professional activities, learning by concordance, orthopaedic education, postgraduate education, script concordance.

Abstract

Traditionally orthopaedic postgraduate education has been focused on knowledge acquisition, case discussions, workplace-based assessment and progressive operative responsibility. These approaches are essential, however many assessment formats still lean toward identification of a single correct answer. In orthopaedics, the clinical practice is different. In many decisions; operative versus non-operative treatment, choice of fixation, reconstruction versus replacement, timing of surgery, and the degree of trainee supervision-judgement is often required under uncertainty. Learning  by Concordance (LbC) is an educational technique where learners are presented with authentic clinical scenarios and asked to respond. Their decisions and reasoning are then compared with those of a panel of experts. Instead of requiring uniformity of opinion, LbC exposes learners to the ways in which experienced clinicians interpret uncertainty and construct defensible decisions. This Short Communication addresses the possible use of LbC in orthopaedic postgraduate education. Recent evidence supporting the use of Script Concordance Testing in surgical and orthopaedic residents provides a specialty-specific rationale for this approach. We propose that LbC could be used to enhance traditional teaching by providing structured case-based reasoning in trauma, arthroscopy, arthroplasty and other areas where there may be more than one reasonable pathway of management. The possibility of extending it to Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) and faculty calibration is also discussed. Further prospective studies are needed to establish its educational effectiveness in orthopaedic training.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-02